Friday, March 8, 2013

Basic Bagel Recipe and Cost Analysis



It seems that my previous post could have been a lot more substantial. Not only could/should I have included the recipes for all of the things mentioned, but I could/should have included information about how much money each one saves me. While for some things, this would be hard to figure out, I will do my best to provide recipes/instructions for most of the items, as well as an idea of how much money you can possibly save. So here's the first one!


BASIC BAGEL

The following recipe is for use in a bread machine. I am sure you can make the same dough by hand, although I am lazy and did not look up how to do it. I will therefore just give you the ingredients and instructions as is and if you would like to make the dough by hand (if you don't have a bread machine), then I'm sure it's pretty easy to look that up.

A few things to note when using a bread machine-add the liquids first, then the dry ingredients. Level the dry ingredients, add the butter to the corners. Make an impression in the center of the dry ingredients and add the yeast. Make another impression away from the yeast and add the salt. The recipe should be baked on the setting for dough.

Ingredients for a 1.5 lb loaf
1 cup water, 80 degrees
3 cups bread flour
2 tbsp sugar
1.5 tsp salt
1.5 tbsp, cut into 6 pieces, butter
2 tsp active dry yeast OR 1.5 tsp bread machine/fast rise yeast

After dough is formed and the breadmaker shuts off, remove the dough from the bread pan and place into a lightly greased bowl. Cover bowl and place in the refrigerator for 20 minutes. After the dough is cooled, remove from the bowl and place on a lightly floured surface. Roll the dough in a 1/2 inch thick rectangle. Divide the dough into 8 equal sections, roll each piece into a ball and punch a hole through the center with your finger. Stretch the hole until it is about 1-2 inches in diameter. Place formed bagels onto a greased cookie sheet about 2 inches apart. Brush lightly with cold water, cover and set in a warm, draft free room to rise until they have doubled in size (1-2 hours).

Bring 3 quarts of water to a boil in a 5 qt dutch oven. Add 1 tbsp of sugar and stir to dissolve. Reduce heat to low and carefully add 2-3 bagels to hot water. Let simmer for 3-4 minutes on each side. Remove with a slotted spoon, drain, then place on the greased baking sheet about an inch apart. Sprinkle with garnish, if desired, and bake bagels in a preheated 450 degrees oven for 12-15 minutes or until golden brown. Let cool slightly before serving.

How Much Does This Save?

This is going to be a tough one to figure out, since the ingredients are things that most people keep on hand always and each item lasts for different amounts of time. I will tell you however that the average price of bagels at my grocery store is $3.99 for 6 bagels. In those 6 bagels you also get things like high fructose corn syrup and other additives, preservatives, dyes and fillers. To be fair, there are brands out there that are a lot healthier and don't have these, but, they still cost about $4-5.

So say just one person in your house eats one bagel 6 days a week, that's $3.99 a week for bagels, so $15.96 a month. If you only take into consideration just the three main ingredients-flour, sugar and butter-here is the breakdown of the cost:

5lb bag of flour: $3.69
4lb bag of sugar: $3.89
4 sticks of butter: $3.49

Using these numbers, I figured out how many of this bagel recipe you can make with each of these, then divided the cost, getting the total cost for each of these items per recipe ($0.55 in flour, $0.09 in sugar and $0.16 in butter per recipe). That means each recipe costs $0.80, and each bagel costs $0.08 to make. So 6 homemade bagels cost $0.60, meaning you can save $15.36 a month on bagels...and that's just if only one person in your house eats bagels!

I will admit that this is one of the more involved recipes and we don’t make it all the time, but they are so cheap to make and can freeze well, too. I hope this at least shows you how a little time can save a lot of money.

Thursday, March 7, 2013

Our Homemade Lives

No-Spend February went pretty well. We only bought one thing that was not food or an absolute necessity, and when I say "we," I mean Jared. He bought an ice-cream maker and tried to sell me on the idea that it was a Valentine's Day present for me. This was funny because A) we don't EVER do anything for Valentine's Day because I think it's a stupid holiday and 2) he has been telling me for a few months how much he wants one. Of course it's funny that he finally broke down and bought one during no-spend month, but what's done is done. It has turned out to be a really great thing to have, especially if you like ice cream but always feel bad buying it because it's expensive and has a lot of unnecessary ingredients in it. Now we have delicious ice cream that isn't chalk full of fillers!

No-Spend February turned out to be an eye-opener, not because we realized how much money we spend on extraneous things (because really, we only saved probably $50 last month) but because of how much money we already save making things at home instead of buying them. Because of this, there wasn't that much we could do to save more money last month. The one thing I did make this month for the first time was yogurt. I got a recipe about a month ago from a friend's blog and finally tried it. I will never buy yogurt again!

Here is a list of things that we make at home:

Yogurt
Bread, including bagels and rolls (using a bread machine)
Granola
Granola bars
Ice Cream (using an ice cream maker)
Sweets (I don't buy cake or cookies or anything of that nature. If we want something sweet, we make it)
Sweet Tea (using a tea maker)
Beer (thanks to Jared!)
Hard Cider (again, thanks to Jared!)
Popcorn (this one is cheating a bit, but what I mean is, we buy kernels and pop it in our own popper which is not only cheaper, but healthier than buying microwave popcorn)
Laundry Detergent

On my list of other things to start making is all other household cleaners, deodorant, soap, lotion and baking mix (like bisquick).

While I am sad that we didn't save hundreds of dollars last month, I guess it's good to know that we really do live pretty frugally already and that we are already doing (mostly) everything we can to limit our spending to things we truly need.

If anyone has any suggestions of things we can make ourselves to save even more money (or to just have something that's more natural and healthy), please comment below and tell me about it!

And for those who are interested, we are still living happily without a microwave :)